Finally after weeks at boot camp at a seemingly auto-tuned judges houses (the audio was so clear for an outside audition) it finally got to the final 16. But no, the girls category was so overly talented that even Simon Cowell admits he was mistaken for not choosing Melanie Amaro.
“I feel it in my gut I’ve made a mistake with someone. I’ve made a big mistake.” Cowell admitted to the other judges after they compared notes to see if there was any act that deserved a second chance.
“The other judges knew who I put through and who I didn’t put through. They were all on the phone immediately going, ‘What were you thinking? And I’ve now got to right a wrong,” Simon said during his trip to Melanie’s house in Florida.
“I want to personally apologize to you and your family for the mistake I made. You were so good. This comes from me and the other judges. We’re going to ask you to come back and enter the competition. We want you on the live shows,” Simon told to Melanie and her family.
Watch the video of the twist below.
So that makes it Top 17 for the first season of X Factor USA.
Meet The Groups namely Lakoda Rayne, The Brewer Boys, InTENsity & The Stereo Hogzz as they are mentored by Paula Abdul.




Meet the Girls - Rachel Crow, Drew Ryniewicz, Melanie Amaro, Simone Battle and Tiah Tolliver as they are mentored by no other than Simon Cowell.





Meet the Boys - Astro (Brian Bradley), Chris Rene, Marcus Canty & Phillip Lomax as they are mentored by no other than L.A. Reid.




And finally Meet the Over 30s - Dexter Haygood, Josh Krajcik, LeRoy Bell & Stacy Francis
as they are mentored by the sexy Nicole Scherzinger.










